Skip to Main Content
The Pizza Cave logo topThe Pizza Cave logo scroll
  • Twitter pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Parties
  • Gift Cards
  • Jobs
  • Order

Our Menu

Menu

Salads / Starters

Antipasto Salad photo

Antipasto Salad

$9.00/Single
$16.00/Family
Greek Salad photo

Greek Salad

$8.00/Single
$14.00/Family
add chicken for $2.00

Caesar Salad

$7.00/Single
$12.00/Family
add chicken for $2.00

Tossed Salad

$7.00/Single
$12.00/Family
add chicken for $2.00

Spinach Tossed Salad

$7.00/Single
$12.00/Family
add chicken for $2.00

Garlic Bread

$3.00/Single
$6.00/Family
add cheese for $1.00 single and $2.00 family

Cheese Breadsticks

$9.00/Family

Breadsticks

$8.00/Family
Garlic Knots photo

Garlic Knots

$4.00/Single
$8.00/Family

Pizza Rolls

$8.00/Single
$14.00/Family
Pepperoni, spinach, sausage (single = 2; family = 4)

Buffalo Dippers

$7.00/Single
$12.00/Family
With a side of blue cheese or ranch (single = 4; family = 8)

Fried Cheese Balls

$8.00/Single
$15.00/Family
Cheese or Cheese/Bacon

Subs/Piadas*

(all made on our fresh made Italian hoagie rolls or piada bread) | Small 6" | Large 12"

Cold Subs:

$0.50 per additional topping

Classic Italian

$10.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Salami, pepperoni, provolone, sautéed peppers

Ham Hoagie

$8.00/Small
$13.00/Large

Hot Subs:

$0.50 per additional topping

Meatball

$10.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Provolone, meatballs and marinara

Pepperoni Melt

$9.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Pepperoni and provolone
Ultimate photo

Ultimate

$9.00/Small
$17.00/Large
Buffalo chicken with mozz, pepperoni, bacon and banana peppers

Brisket

$10.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Joe's BBQ sauce, brisket, onions and pickles
Cheesesteak photo

Cheesesteak

$9.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Marinated ribeye, sauteed onion/bell peppers, and provolone

Texas Cheesesteak

$9.00/Small
$15.00/Large
Our mesquite smoked brisket, sauteed red bell/banana peppers and white American cheese on a toasted hoagie

Piadas:

$0.50 per additional topping

Select a Meat (Sausage, Beef OR Chicken)

$8.00/Small
$14.00/Large
Piada sauce, romaine, tomato, red onion
Classic Italian photo

Classic Italian

$10.00/Small
$16.00/Large
Provolone, salami, pepperoni, piada sauce, romaine, tomato, red onion)
Brisket photo

Brisket

$10.00/Small
$16.00/Large
Piada sauce, brisket, onion, pickles

Soups

(Piggie Chowder, Tomato Basil or Soup of the Day)

Soup photo

Soup

$4.00/Cup
$8.00/Bowl
$19.00/32 oz.

Calzones and Strombolis

Classic Calzone photo

Classic Calzone

$15.00
Ricotta cheese, mozzarella and ham

Veggie Calzone

$15.00
Ricotta cheese, mozzarella, broccoli and onion

Spinach Calzone

$14.00
Ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach

Build Your Own Calzone

$15.00
Ricotta cheese, mozzarella and up to 4 toppings of your choice
Classic Stromboli photo

Classic Stromboli

$15.00
Mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, sautéed bell peppers and onions

Build Your Own Stromboli

$15.00
Mozzarella and up to 4 toppings of your choice

Pastas

Spaghetti Marinara

$12.00
Angel hair pasta, marinara sauce. Add $1.00 for meat sauce

Spaghetti and Meatballs

$15.00
Angel hair pasta with 4 meatballs

Meatballs and Marinara

$10.00
4 meatballs with marinara - no pasta

Meatballs and Arrabiata

$11.00
4 meatballs with arrabbiata and Grana Padano cheese - no pasta
Lasagna photo

Lasagna

$16.00
Susan’s seven-layer lasagna – is really tasty!

Stuffed Shells

$12.00

Pizza

Pizza dough made daily in our store

Specialty Pies :

Buffalo Chicken Pie

$20.00/Small 12"
$22.00/Gluten Free 12''
$26.00/Medium 15"
$31.00/Large 18"
Mozz, chicken, blue cheese, buffalo sauce
Margherita Pie photo

Margherita Pie

$19.00/Small 12"
$21.00/Gluten Free 12''
$24.00/Medium 15"
$29.00/Large 18"
Fresh mozz, romas and basil

Pepper and Onion Pie

$20.00/Small 12"
$22.00/Gluten Free 12''
$26.00/Medium 15"
$31.00/Large 18"
Mozz, sauteed green bell and onion

BBQ Pie - Chicken,Beef or Brisket

$20.00/Small 12"
$22.00/Gluten Free 12''
$26.00/Medium 15"
$31.00/Large 18"
Mozz, meat, onion and BBQ sauce

Classic White Pie

$19.00/Small 12''
$21.00/Gluten Free 12''
$24.00/Medium 15"
$29.00/Large 18"
Mozz, ricotta and fresh garlic

Basil Pesto (Green) Pie

$18.00/Small 12''
$20.00/Gluten Free 12''
$23.00/Medium 15"
$27.00/Large 18"
Mozz and basil pesto

Chicken and Broccoli Pie

$19.00/Small 12''
$21.00/Gluten Free 12''
$24.00/Medium 15"
$29.00/Large 18"

Loaded Meat Pie

$22.00/Small 12''
$24.00/Gluten Free 12''
$29.00/Medium 15"
$35.00/Large 18"
Mozz, pep, sausage, ham, meatball and salami

Loaded Veggie Pie

$23.00/Small 12''
$25.00/Gluten Free 12''
$29.00/Medium 15"
$35.00/Large 18"
Mozz, lots of veggies...

Hawaiian Pie

$19.00/Small 12''
$21.00/Gluten Free 12''
$24.00/Medium 15"
$29.00/Large 18"
Mozz, ham and pineapple

Alfredo Pie

$21.00/Small 12''
$23.00/Gluten Free 12''
$27.00/Medium 15"
$33.00/Large 18"
Mozz, alfredo sauce, chicken, garlic and spinach
The Spelunker photo

The Spelunker

$23.00/Small 12''
$25.00/Gluten Free 12''
$29.00/Medium 15"
$35.00/Large 18"
Mozz, pep, sausage, red onion, bell, mushroom, black olives

Sicilian Pie (16X16 Square)

$25.00/Medium 16"

Build Your Own Pie

Individual 9": Plain Pie $8.50 plus $0.50 per topping

Plain Cheese Pie

$17.00/Small 12"
$19.00/Gluten Free 12"
$21.00/Medium 15"
$25.00/Large 18"

One Topping Pie

$18.00/Small 12"
$20.00/Gluten Free 12"
$23.00/Medium 15"
$27.00/Large 18"

Two Topping Pie

$19.00/Small 12"
$21.00/Gluten Free 12"
$24.00/Medium 15"
$29.00/Large 18"

Three Topping Pie

$20.00/Small 12"
$22.00/Gluten Free 12"
$26.00/Medium 15"
$31.00/Large 18"

Four Topping Pie

$21.00/Small 12"
$23.00/Gluten Free 12"
$27.00/Medium 15"
$33.00/Large 18"

Five Topping Pie

$22.00/Small 12"
$24.00/Gluten Free 12"
$29.00/Medium 15"
$35.00/Large 18"

*Substitute Alfredo Or Pesto For Pizza Sauce:

$1.00/Gluten Free 12"
$1.00/Small 12"
$1.50/Medium 15"
$2.00/Large 18"

Price Per Topping:

$1.00/Small 12"
$1.00/Gluten Free 12"
$1.50/Medium 15"
$2.00/Large 18"

Toppings

Pepperoni | Brisket | Anchovies | Fresh Garlic | Salami | Onions | Mushrooms | Ham | Sausage |Black Olives | Jalapenos | Chicken | Red Onions | Broccoli | Bell Peppers | Meatball | Green Olives | Spinach | Bacon | Roma Tomato |Pineapple | Fresh Basil
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Jobs